What's a Good Paprika Substitute?
Answer: No, they’re not directly interchangeable. When comparing paprika to crushed red pepper, it’s important to know that these two spices differ significantly in flavor and heat. Paprika, often made from sweeter peppers, provides color and a mild taste without much heat. Crushed red pepper, made from hotter peppers and seeds, offers a spicy kick. Substituting one for the other can change your dish’s flavor and spice level significantly, as paprika is milder and more about flavor, while crushed red pepper is all about adding heat.
When substituting, use common sense. Cayenne pepper is as much as 50 times hotter than sweet paprika, so a 1:1 substitution wouldn't work unless you want some heat—the right substitution, in this case, would be 1/3 of a teaspoon of cayenne per 1 teaspoon of paprika. Make an informed decision, but also use thorough recipes that might suggest reasonable substitutions.
The most vital of those ingredients is the Golden Goose Egg Secret #1 of making delicious Chiu Chow sauce at home: garlic. Lots and lots of it—enough to ward off potential dates within a 10-mile radius. Enough to scare the vampires out of your kids’ nightmares. Yes. That much.
You have a few options when it comes to spicy ketchup. You can easily make it yourself (see our recipe for smoky chipotle ketchup) or you can buy one of the many options available at most grocery stores. Heinz also carries a chili sauce in its line (affiliate link) that’s really much more like spicy ketchup than a Sriracha.
Paprika powder is used to add flavor, color, and sometimes a mild heat to a wide variety of dishes. Its versatility makes it a popular spice in many cuisines. Some common uses of paprika powder include: